Double Email Notification - Learning the Site

Ok, so I'm getting double email notifications when someone posts a comment to my blog.  There are two places to put in an email address and I have both set.  This is under the Settings tab, then the Comments section.

---------- And ----------

So, I've taken my email address out of the first one and I will post a comment and see what happens but I wonder if I should take it out of the second one and leave the first one?

Edit 1: After the first two comments, I received one email each. Yay! However, both were published to my blog without moderation required.  For me commenting as me, that makes sense because lord knows I don't need to censor myself, but the one I posted as Anonymous was also published without my approval.  Is that because I'm still signed in and the site recognized me anyhow? So, now I will log out and post a comment anonymously.

Edit 2: I was about to say I didn't get the notification for comment 3 posted truly anonymously, but right after I signed back in here to check and I published it, I got the email. Maybe I didn't wait long enough.

Edit 3: Nope. I goofed. It sent me the email after I published the comment to tell me there was a new comment.  So, it's not doing what I want it to do now. :(

So, let's take the email address out of the second spot and put it in the top one.  That prolly makes more sense anywho since I want notification of new comments to approve and I really don't need an email telling me I clicked the publish button.

Edit 4: Yay! That works like I want it too. Now if some registered user will post me a comment, I can see if it works when they post since the site is smart enough to not require me to moderate my own comments to myself. lol

Edit 5: Thank you, Dakota. It is now working exactly like I want it too. I get an email when there are comments to moderate whether it's a registered member or anonymous and no email when I publish them. Yay! Problem solved.

Edit 6: Ok, so now I changed my mind and turned off the moderation so the comments will appear as soon as they are posted while still leaving anonymous allowed. I'll see how that goes.